Archive for Editorials/Essays – Page 5

Sedona Redrock News responds sharply to Wills’ effort to blame paper should shakey deal collapse

Larson Newspapers Managing Editor editorial blasts Wills’ comments at June 9 District Board meeting

The Managing Editor of the Sedona Red Rock News, Christopher Fox Graham, blasted Dr. Penelope Wills for her comments about the newspaper, its editorials, and cartoons in the June 24 issue of the Sedona Red Rock News. In her update to the Yavapai College board at its June 9 meeting, Penelope Wills blamed Larson Newspapers for the potential loss of the $4.5 million DK Ranch land donation in the Verde Valley.  She cited a cartoon and an editorial without naming the newspaper, which was obviously the Sedona Red Rock News.

Christopher Fox Graham

Christopher Fox Graham

In his editorial response to the Wills’ accusations, Mr. Graham wrote that Wills’ incorrectly stated to the Board that the News had “submitted what I consider a very inappropriate cartoon and an editorial . . ..” He stated that “In fact the News did not submit anything to Steele Foundation or the land broker.”

On Wills’ failure to identify the News when speaking to the Board, Mr. Graham wrote that “she would at least have mentioned our newspaper by name. Since she apparently spends so little time on this side of Mingus Mountain and even less so thinking about the value of Verde Valley taxpayers, I’m not surprised she doesn’t know the names of any Verde Valley publications, though we’re flattered she knows our impact in the community.”

Mr. Graham also stated that “There have been dozens of letters to the editor from you, our loyal readers, condemning the college’s behavior and its 10-Year Plan. I have not seen one letter advocating the college collect our $12 million per year while only returning a fraction of that in capital improvements over the next decade. Nor have any suggested dumping our tax money on a new college campus in the vacant Prescott Valley area is a good idea. None have applauded the college for slashing Verde Valley education programs like the climax of a samurai film.”

There is much more. The entire editorial written by Mr. Graham can be accessed and read by clicking here.

Redrock News slams tax increase

Editorial charges College wants more but offers nothing–but happy to steal our cash

A May 22, 2015  editorial written by Red Rock News managing editor, Christoper Fox Graham, blistered the Community College for asking for a property tax increase while offering little more in educational programs in the Verde Valley.

Mr. Graham charged that “despite meetings and seeming steps toward equanimity, the college has yet to listen as it has not made any changes to its 10-year plan.”  He pointed out that the Verde Campus Executive Dean who is the “best advocate for the Verde Valley has no real community connection to his students other than having an occasionally-used office on this side of the mountain.”

Christopher Fox Graham

Christopher Fox Graham

Graham observed that “the college already raised tuition and fees on students and now, to add insult to injury, the college is asking for as much as a 2 percent property tax increase to help pay for the misguidance in shifting programs and construction projects away from Verde Valley taxpayers who are asked to foot the increased bill.”

He concluded that “a county community college is supposed to serve all county residents equally. Yavapai College hasn’t and it appears that short of a lawsuit or secession from the taxing district or even the county, college officials will continue to ignore us but be happy to steal our cash.”

The complete editorial may be read by clicking here.

College alters view of how capital projects financed

Voters no longer are sought to provide approval of major capital projects–Community College development has sufficient funds from tuition and property taxes 

Commentary

Commentary

The historic view followed by public education institutions that voters must approve a major capital project via a General Obligation bond  is no longer the Yavapai Community College philosophy. Because of its power to raise property taxes by a three member vote of the District Governing Board and increase tuition at will, the Community College is now able to build major capital projects without asking for voter approval.  This is a huge change in philosophy and means that the Community College is now being run much like a private company. The only difference is that it has a constant stream of revenue coming from County property taxes and student tuition.  Voters have lost almost total control over capital projects.

The old view is expressed in the Community College 1999 Master Plan.  In that plan, the College wrote:   

“As a public community college district, the primary mechanism for renovation and construction projects is the issuance of general obligation bonds approved by the voters of Yavapai County. However, the College’s goal is to maximize the use of other funding sources to support key elements of the Facilities Plan.”

The old philosophy is found throughout that plan.  For example, funding for a new soccer field, a renovated baseball field, and new tennis courts was all to come from donated funds–not from taxpayers. 

Under the new approach, the College has managed to carve out a budget from annual property taxes and tuition so that it can build without voter approval any capital project it fancies.  (Once it was thought by some that using taxpayer money at a publicly funded institution for capital development was unethical.)  For example, without voter approval, it announced a $119 million dollar development project that it intends to finance over ten years from 2014-2024. It never asked for voter approval.

As Dr. Wills stated at the February 2014 Board meeting where the ten-year plan was discussed:   “We are not going out for a General Obligation bond” for any [of the ten-year development plan.]

Vice President Clint Ewell explained at the February, 2014 meeting where the money for the ten-year plan was coming.  He said:  

“Revenues are coming from property tax and savings that we have accumulated over the past few years. . . . On average we are reinvesting about $8 million dollars a year although it ranges as low as $6 million and as high as $12 million in a given year.” (February 2014 Governing Board.)

The implications of this major policy change and operation of the Community College, which began about seven years ago, is troubling.  The College no longer needs to seek input from residents of the County before millions of dollars are invested in major development.  It can invest in any project that it fancies knowing that voters would never approve it.  Residents of Yavapai County are no longer in control of their County Community College.  It has been turned over to bureaucrats who have had no serious opposition from the Governing Board in spending millions of dollars on plant development–rather than faculty salaries, more faculty, and better overall education.  Hopefully, with two new members on the Governing Board, automatic rubber stamping of capital projects will end. 

Verde Valley on the losing side of history

Essay provides a short history of the contest between the Verde Valley and Prescott over location and operation of Yavapai Community College

Analysis

Analysis

History is the witness that testifies to the passing of time; it illumines reality, vitalizes memory, provides guidance in daily life, and brings us tidings of antiquity.
Marcus Tullius Cicero

There is a long history of political domination of the West side of the County over the East side. Domination began in 1966-67 when there was a fierce contest between the citizens in the Verde Valley and those in Prescott over where the first Community College would be located. The Gulf States and Industries Corporation offered $1.5 million dollars in financing for student dormitories and a student center, an outright gift of $100,000 for building purposes, and 165 acres of what was described as “prime land in the Clarkdale area” of the Verde Valley.

A site review conducted by Northern Arizona University recommended Clarkdale as the most desirable location for the first Yavapai Community College. Despite the site review and the offer by the Gulf States and Industries Corporation, the Verde Valley failed in its effort to establish the first community college there.  Rather, Prescott was  selected by the State Junior College Board as the location for the Community College.

Voters on May 23, 1967 approved 3011 to 2904 (107 margin) a $2.5 million dollar bond for the creation of Yavapai College.  It is said that almost everyone in the Verde Valley voted against the proposal because of their anger over the decision by the State Junior College Board to not locate the college in the Verde Valley.

In 1975 another dispute arose between the Verde Valley and Prescott over the Community College. The dispute was twofold: When would initial construction of the Verde campus begin? Could the Verde campus be administratively separated from the control of Prescott? The buildings were eventually constructed on the Verde campus but the idea of a separate administrative college modeled after those in Maricopa County was rejected.  Read More→

Comprehensive review of campus projects and plans since 1994

Complete collection of Master plans, visions, projects, undertaken since 1994 now available in one pdf file

FUTURE PLANThe Blog has gathered together in one pdf file a history of College Master plans and documents created by others related to the College. The material goes from 1994 to 2013. and others since 1994.  There is an emphasis on the plans and visions for the future of the Verde Valley.    You can access the actual plans, visions and projects as they were actually written and presented by clicking here. MASTER_PLANS_VISIONS_PROJECTS_1994 TO 2014.  

Mystery of Film School Collapse

Booklet examines the reasons Sedona and Verde Valley residents were stunned when the Community College announced the closing of the Sedona Film School

FILM SCHOOL COLAPSE COVER OF BOOKLETThis Blog is committed to bringing to its readers the facts behind decisions made by the Yavapai Community College administrators that affect the residents of Sedona and the Verde Valley.  One of the most bewildering decisions was the complete turn-about of the Community College in handling the Sedona Film school.

A 23 page booklet, written by the Blog editor,  uses media reports and other sources of information to follow the College’s actions relative to the Film School over a two-year period prior to closing the program.  It also asks the College to provide dollar and cents support for its claim it was subsidizing the Film School to the tune of $300,000 annually. How do you think the College  responded to that question?   

By clicking here, you will be taken to the booklet.  Enjoy.  MYSTERY OF WHY SEDONA FILM SCHOOL CLOSED.

Wicks’ editorial in Verde Independent

Ruth Wicks applauds cooperation from College but looks for action

Ruth Wicks, who has been a leader in the effort to bring about major change in the Community College educational opportunities of students and adults in the Verde Valley, asked for cooperation and looked for action in her recent “My Turn” column in the Verde Independent.

Ms. Ruth Wicks

Wicks wrote that “the leadership of the college appears presently to be listening to our needs and concerns. There is talk about not transferring the Nursing program to Prescott and reinstating the Digital Media and Film program. Another indicator of their willingness to work with us is the stunning reversal to not sell the Sedona campus as was voted on by our Yavapai College District Governing Board in the adoption of the Ten Year Plan.”

She also wrote that: “Actions speak louder than words and we await the college’s actual investment of monies, staff, programs and the creation of our own college, Verde Valley Community College, under the auspices of Yavapai College.”

Her complete  editorial may be found in the Verde Independent by clicking here.

Booklet examines Career and Technology in Yavapai County

What is the future for Career and Technology training opportunity in the Verde Valley?

COVER FUTURE OF CTE TRAINING IN THE VERDE VALLEYA 23 page fact-based booklet reviewing the future of Career and Technology Education (CTE) opportunities in the Verde Valley has been published.  

The booklet  provides background information about CTE training on the East and West sides of the County and shows the enormous difference currently existing in learning opportunities.  It can be read in PDF format by clicking here.CTE BOOKLET

Student concerned with disconnect and shifting programs to Prescott

Verde Student expresses concern with so few students on Verde campus; shifting programs to Prescott; disconnect between College and citizens

Yavapai College student Judy Jaaskelainen expressed her concern with the absence of students on the Verde campus and an absence of local citizens connecting with the College in a letter to the editor on October 17 in the Verde Independent.

Ms. Jaaskelainen wrote that she attended the Art and Craft Fair held last Saturday on the Verde campus where there were many artists and crafts-person booths inside and outside at the Mabery Pavilion. They included booths showing fine jewelry, sachets, pottery, candles, books, scarves, paintings, glass art, beaded jewelry, fabric items, and more. There was also a booth set up for children to decorate items using potato stamps and also a face painting booth.

Adding to the event were onstage local musicians, Wendy Harford and Jo Agostinelli, who sang original songs and Dave Rentz. In her words:

I am sad to say, the attendance to this event was very poor. I was the ONLY person sitting in the rows and rows of chairs arranged for the anticipated audience. And there were very few people shopping at the art and craft booths.

 I have been a student at this campus for about 13 years, taking various computer classes and art classes each semester. I remember when there were so many people attending classes at this Clarkdale campus of Yavapai College that we had to stand in line for 10-15 minutes to grab a sandwich or a snack from the campus snack bar.

I attend a class now on Wed. afternoons. I am amazed at how few people are walking around campus.
I plan to contact Ruth Wicks and others who are attempting to “fix” whatever is wrong with our campus to see how I can help with their endeavor. With the nursing program and other pertinent programs having been shifted over the mountain, we need to focus on getting them back.

The money invested by the residents of our community should be used to further the education of the young people graduating from our local high schools, including those who want to be nurses.
Something is not right when people in the community do not attend a free, fun event at their Community College.

Apathy is unacceptable but understandable when the people do not feel a connection nor commitment to their local college.

Ms. Jaaskelainen’s letter to the editor in full can be found by clicking here, which will take you to the Verde Independent

Student laments Verde campus lack of class offerings

Essay outlines the feelings and views of student on Clarkdale campus about insufficient classes; creating a campus independent of Prescott

Yavapai Community College student Ms. Deb Wilson wrote an essay sharing  some of her feelings and views about the Clarkdale campus and its deficiencies.  The essay is entitled, “Where are the students?”  It is set out in full below.

WHERE ARE TH E STUDENTS?

It is 9:00 a.m. on opening day of classes at the Clarkdale (Verde Valley) Campus of Yavapai “Community” College, aka, Yavapai College. Where is everybody, I ask myself? I glance at the many empty parking spots, as I walk the empty pathway toward a tent and table set up near the Administration Building.

Bags are being handed out to the few students in the area, including me. With my little bag came a printout of all the activities going on that week. The first was a free lunch that day. Each course was being served in different buildings. I asked the person behind the tent table if all these activities were in Prescott, or here in Clarkdale. “Oh, here,” she answered.

This is such an obvious distraction, I think to myself: offering free lunch and “fun” stuff, but not offering the courses students want and need. I take the same class every semester, probably because only jewelry, ceramics, and a few other art courses are available in Clarkdale. Just a few of Prescott’s art & trade offerings include: Painting, ceramics, photography, sculpture, graphic design, gunsmithing, woodworking, drawing, jewelry, and several other art forms and advanced art forms NOT offered in Clarkdale.

My friend, David (name has been changed), a non- traditional student, started working toward an Associate Degree a year ago. The first couple of classes he took were easy to find in Clarkdale’s class schedule. Like David, I avoided “have to take” classes my first semester in college, because I hadn’t been to school in a long time, and wanted to enjoy the classes I took, and to get my brain reactivated. As ALL VERDE VALLEY RESIDENTS SHOULD KNOW, and as David found out when it was time to get serious about his major interest, there were few classes he needed, or wanted, available in Clarkdale. Read More→